Last spring, I bought a few acres one town over, along with the old house on them. The man who owned it had passed away, and his family sold the place with the root cellar dug into the hillside out back. I knew him a little from the feed store, a quiet fellow who never threw anything away. And once we pried the cellar door open, we found shelves of food he’d stored over three decades, from a case of ’90s MREs to home-canned jars with his handwriting on the lids. My wife took one look and asked if I was hauling it all to the dump.
I told her I’d taste some of it first. That man put real work into those shelves, and I didn’t want it wasted without a fair try. I wanted to know what food stored for decades actually tastes like, and whether any of it would keep a family going in a pinch.
So I spent a couple of Saturdays going through what he’d left behind, nose first and then mouth. Some of it held up better than I expected. Some of it went straight in the trash, and I’ll tell you why.
Eating 30-Year-Old Military MREs
The case had a date code of 6045 stamped on the side. MRE cases use a Julian date, so the first digit is the year and the next three are the day. That put these meals at February 14, 1996, the same era of rations our troops carried in Bosnia.
I picked a beef stew menu and checked the entree pouch before anything else. It lay flat, with no puffing and no oily residue on the outside. The stew looked darker than I remembered, and the potatoes had gone soft as baby food. Still, it smelled like beef stew, and the flavor came through mostly intact.
But the crackers didn’t fare nearly as well, since they tasted like the cardboard box they came in and broke into dust. The cheese spread had turned tan and grainy, though it still tasted like cheese.
Then came the pound cake, which surprised me most. It crumbled the second I tore the pouch, dry and stale like an old sponge. So I broke it into a bowl and poured cold milk over it. After about five minutes, it softened up and tasted close to vanilla cake, and I finished the bowl.
Mind you, that case lasted on luck as much as packaging, and half the menu tasted like the box it came in. Plus, fresh military MREs with years of shelf life left cost a small fortune today, and you get no say over what goes inside.
The better move is to keep these 7 MREs in your stockpile, packed after the military “one meal or one day” rule. That means you can build a single-meal pack around the numbers of a real Army MRE, which provides about 1,285 calories, including 40 grams of protein, 176 grams of carbohydrates, and 47 grams of fat.
And a full-day pack can match the Army’s First Strike Ration, where each FSR (food for 24 hours) provides around 2,900 calories, including 91 grams of protein, 421 grams of carbohydrates, and 98 grams of fat. Better yet, you pick every item yourself, so your family will actually eat what’s in the bag.
Here’s how to do it:

Tasting 17-Year-Old Homemade Pemmican
He’d made two batches of pemmican and marked both tubs 2009 in black marker. They sat sealed on the lowest shelf, in the coolest corner of the cellar. The first was plain, just lean beef dried hard, pounded to powder, and mixed with rendered beef tallow. The second had dried blueberries and cranberries worked in for flavor.
Thankfully, the plain batch still looked the way he must have packed it, a dense, pale brown brick. I shaved off a piece with my pocketknife and let it warm up in my mouth. It tasted like strong beef jerky with a waxy coating, and the tallow left a faint stale note at the back of my throat. I wouldn’t serve it at a family dinner, but I’d eat it without complaint if needed.
The fruit batch, though, failed the smell test the moment I popped the lid. A sour, almost winey smell came off it, and the fat had a sharp rancid edge, so I set it aside without tasting it.
That plain brick held up for 17 years with nothing but dried beef and fat holding it together. No wonder fur traders and Arctic explorers trusted pemmican to carry them through months with no other food in their packs.
To make pemmican that lasts that long in your own pantry, start with the original 1743 pemmican recipe and follow it the way the trappers did, ratios and all. Find the full recipe here. Then give the berries their own sealed bag, and mix them in the day you eat.
Franco-American Canned Pasta From the Late ’90s
Anyone who grew up on canned pasta remembers Franco-American. Campbell’s dropped the name from its pasta in 2004, so the cans on his shelf had to be older than that, and you won’t find that label in a store today. He had a can of their macaroni and cheese and a can of Superiore beef ravioli tucked behind the newer stuff.
The macaroni can looked clean, with no rust on the seams and no swelling on either end. It opened the way a good can should, with no spurt of liquid and no sour smell. Inside, the sauce had darkened from bright orange to a muddy brownish color. And the noodles had soaked up so much liquid they mashed against the roof of my mouth like paste.
Still, I heated it in a pot and gave it a fair shot. The cheese flavor was weak, but it tasted like food, with a mild metallic aftertaste. My kids would’ve turned their nose up at it, though a hungry man in a bad winter would clean the bowl.
Store-bought canned pasta loses a lot over the years, and that macaroni came out mushy with a metallic aftertaste. You’ll get a much better meal by keeping your pasta dry and canning the hearty part yourself.
That’s where this famous Poor Man’s Steak recipe comes in, since you can put up a few jars of it before the cold sets in. Then just pour a jar over some freshly boiled pasta, and you’ve got a real meal when SHTF, or simply on a cold winter evening after work.
Home-Canned Food After 12 and 13 Years
The old man kept a big garden, and the cellar held a few dozen jars he’d canned over the years. Some were labeled 2013 and 2014 in his shaky handwriting, and those were the only ones I tasted. For each one, I checked that the lid stayed concave and didn’t flex when I pressed the center.
The pressure-canned green beans from 2013 had faded to an olive drab color and turned soft. Low-acid home-canned food can carry botulism without any smell or swelling, so I boiled them hard for ten minutes before tasting. After that, they tasted like ordinary canned green beans, just mushier, and a pat of butter fixed most of it.
As for the 2014 peaches, they held up better than anything else I tried. The fruit at the top of the jar had browned, and the syrup had turned amber. Even so, they were sweet and soft, and my wife ate a few slices with me straight from the jar.
Those green beans came out soft and olive drab because pressure canning cooks them once in the jar, and the years on a shelf keep softening them after that. The peaches hid it under sweet syrup, but plain vegetables have nothing to hide behind.
Freeze-drying solves that problem, and you don’t need a store-bought machine that costs thousands to do it. With the homemade freeze-drier that keeps food for 25+ years, your garden beans hold on to their color and flavor, and they take up a fraction of the shelf space a row of jars would.
A Nice Surprise…

Behind the jars, he’d lined up a few wicker-wrapped demijohns and some green corked bottles, each dated on masking tape. Turns out the old man made his own wine, from a 2016 bottle to a 2024 jug.
The 2016 cork crumbled halfway out, since the bottle had stood upright for years and let air creep in. The wine had turned brick-brown and tasted flat and nutty, like cheap sherry, so now my wife cooks with it.
The 2024 jug had its cork sealed under wax, and it poured bright red and tasted fruity, if a little rough. We each finished a glass that evening, and these days any wine we store goes on its side with a dip of wax over the cork.
The Old Food I Wouldn’t Touch, and Why
That Franco-American ravioli can had both ends domed outward. If I pressed one end down, the other popped up, and that’s a sign gas built up inside from bacterial growth. So it went into a doubled trash bag without being opened, since even a spray of that liquid on your hands can make you sick.
Two of the MRE entree pouches had also puffed up like little pillows. The rest of the case looked fine, but I wasn’t about to gamble on a swollen pouch from 1996. And I already told you about the fruit pemmican, which smelled bad enough to settle the question.
Then there were about a dozen jars with no label at all. Some looked like green beans and some looked like stew meat, but I couldn’t tell when he canned them. More important, I couldn’t tell whether he’d pressure-canned them or used a water bath, and low-acid food done in a water bath is a botulism risk. I dumped every one of those jars, even the ones with good seals.
What This Taste Test Taught Me About Long-Term Food Storage
My wife still thinks I’m a little crazy for eating a 30-year-old beef stew. But that old man’s cellar showed me how our own stored food will hold up over the years. And I’d like to think he’d be glad it all got a fair try.
So after two Saturdays in that cellar, I changed a few things about how we store food at home:
- Boil low-acid home-canned food before you eat it. Botulism gives you no smell and no bulge to warn you, but ten minutes at a rolling boil destroys the toxin. That’s why it’s mandatory to learn the 5 early signs of botulism poisoning now, while you still have a doctor to call.
- Mark every jar with the canning method. Our lids now get the contents, the year, and PC or WB for pressure canner or water bath. A jar of green beans marked WB goes straight in the trash, since a water bath can’t kill botulism spores in low-acid food.
- Keep fruit and fat apart. The plain pemmican outlasted the berry batch by years, because the fruit brought in moisture and sugar that turned the tallow rancid.
- Store food where you’d want to sleep in July. The military rates MREs for about 130 months at 60°F, yet at 100°F that drops below two years. That case survived because a hillside cellar holds a steady temperature. If your land is flat, the backyard cellar that stays cool all summer can do the same job without a hill.
- Put the oldest food up front. Those Franco-American cans sat behind newer stuff for over 20 years. Now new cans go in from the back, and we always eat from the front. Better yet, build the gravity shelf that rotates cans for you and you’ll never lose a can behind the others again.
- Keep pasta dry and add the sauce later. Dry pasta in a sealed bucket holds its texture for decades, and a can of sauce beside it gives you the same meal. Also, stock these 4 shelf-stable sauces that last for years, and a bucket of noodles turns into a real supper.
- Stock something to soak old food in. That stale pound cake came back to life after five minutes in milk; same with crackers in broth. That’s why we keep powdered milk next to the long-term food. Even the Civil War hardtack that never spoils turns soft and filling once you drop it in a hot bowl of broth.
- Check your shelves on a schedule. Twice a year, I press every can end and jar lid, and I make sure each pouch still lies flat.
- Eat your oldest can once a year. Each fall, we open the oldest thing in the house and have it for supper. It shows us how food ages in our own basement, and it keeps the rotation from slipping.
Build a Stockpile That Holds Up
That old man spent 30 years filling those shelves, and still a good share of his work went straight to the dump.
So to make sure every jar you seal this fall is still safe to open in 2050, you can learn the old preserving methods in The Lost Frontier Handbook and avoid the mistakes that quietly spoil a stockpile.

This way you will learn:
- How to make the 100-year survival ration fur trappers and Arctic explorers carried for months with no other food
- 3 ways to keep food cold through a summer blackout, from a root cellar to a long-lost evaporation trick
- How to smoke and cure meat, so a deer you take in November still feeds you in May
- The Civil War biscuit that won’t go bad in any climate, and softens into a filling meal once you soak it in broth
- The food-spoiling dangers that can wipe out a pantry, so you catch them while the rest of the shelf is still good
As for that cellar, it’s filling back up with our own jars, each one marked with the year and PC or WB on the lid. So if somebody pries that door open in 2056, they won’t have to guess what’s safe to eat.
You may also like:
How to Preserve Bacon for a 5+ Year Shelf Life (VIDEO + PHOTO)
Ultimate Home Medical Supplies Checklist
9 Ways You Can Repurpose Expired Food Cans
If You Live in THIS State, You Have Gold in Your Backyard
What Happens If You Put Silver In Milk?
The post I Taste-Tested Survival Food From the 1990s. Here’s How It Held Up appeared first on Ask a Prepper.
from Ask a Prepper https://ift.tt/xEuoKjQ