Submissions     Contact     Advertise     Donate     BlogRoll     Subscribe                         

Wednesday, October 10, 2012

12 Myths of Disaster Preparedness

Original Article

Disaster Dozen - by Paul Purcell
From Emergency Management Magazine

Hurricane Katrina and other disasters have given us a series of emergency preparedness wake-up calls. Do we pay attention now or continue to hit the snooze button?

Let’s look at the most important part of a comprehensive emergency readiness plan: the preparedness levels of individuals and families.

The biggest obstacles to comprehensive family emergency readiness education are the misconceptions surrounding the true nature of preparedness. So to set the stage for better education, and ultimately better public safety, let’s take a look at some of these myths.

1. If something happens all I have to do is call 911.

Help can only go so far or be there so quickly. Security, like charity, begins at home and the responsibility for your family’s safety rests on your shoulders. This isn’t to say that families shouldn’t call for help when it’s truly needed, it’s to remind them that they may be on their own for a while, especially if the situation is expansive or severe.

2. All I need is a 72-hour kit with a flashlight, first aid kit, some food and water, and a radio.

We’re not sure where the 72-hour figure came from but it’s an extremely minimal amount of time and not very realistic. A more practical goal is to be self-sufficient for a minimum of two weeks (preferably four weeks). Why two weeks? As bad as Katrina was there are numerous disaster and terrorism scenarios that could yield substantially more damage and a disruption of local services for three weeks or more. Also many biological scenarios may cause a two-week quarantine. Avoid the one-size-fits-all simpleton lists and customize yours to your family’s unique threats, needs and assets.

3. My insurance policy will take care of everything.

SWAT teams of insurance agents aren’t going to instantly rebuild your life like on TV. Insurance companies will be far more concerned about their own bottom line than yours. In fact, many insurance companies are rewriting policies to redefine some rather common terrorism or disaster-related incidents as being excluded and not coverable. Check your policies closely.

4. Good preparedness is too expensive and complicated.

Nothing could be further from the truth. The problem is we haven’t made preparedness part of our overall education. We get more preparedness information on an airline flight than we get as citizens. Most citizens aren’t taught that there are literally thousands of subtle, simple and economical things we can do to drastically improve our emergency readiness. The notion that it might be expensive or complicated has come from companies that aggressively market high-priced unnecessary gear.

5. We can only form a neighborhood group through FEMA, the Red Cross or local law enforcement.

Neighbor helping neighbor is one of our highest civic duties. No one regulates this, and you don’t have to get anyone’s permission to coordinate your safety with others. Working with these groups is rather advantageous but not require.

6. In a weapons of mass destruction (WMD) terrorist attack, we’re all dead anyway.

WMDs might kill larger numbers of people, but that doesn’t mean widespread destruction is guaranteed. In fact, for widespread destruction a top-grade WMD must be expertly and precisely applied under ideal conditions. This does not mean that WMDs are to be ignored or that they’re nothing to fear, it’s just that mass destruction does not mean total destruction.

7. Nothing like that could ever happen here.

Though some areas are more prone to certain types of disasters, say earthquakes in California or terror attacks in New York, no area is completely immune. Travelers might travel somewhere and wind up in a disaster they never thought about.

8. All I have to worry about is my own family.

Technically yes but the more you’re able to care for your own family, the more you can and should help others.

9. If preparedness were really important it would be taught in school.

Preparedness really is that important but schools only have so much time and budget to teach the topics they already do. This is one of the many things we’re trying to change.

10. I can get free preparedness information on the Internet.

Many free sources contain really good information. However, many of them are nothing more than a rehash of 72-hour kit ideas and contain nothing new or comprehensive. Also it takes time and experience to filter the trash from the treasure. And some of these free sites have information that could actually cause more problems than they solve. Start with, but don’t stop there, continue your education as best you can.

11. Full preparedness means I have to get a lot of guns and be a survivalist.

While personal security and family safety are valid concerns, the vast majority of people around you will not be a threat. In fact, though looters gained a lot of media attention after Hurricane Katrina, there were far more stories of heroism and of people making new friends through shared adversity. We suggest a balance between personal security needs with the desire to help others.

12. If something really bad happens, no one will help.

There’s no such thing as “no one helping.” However, the best thing people can do to is to prepare their families so they need as little outside help as possible. There’s always someone needier than you and the more prepared you are, the more you free up assistance resources so they can help those less fortunate.

Paul Purcell is an Atlanta-based security analyst and preparedness consultant with more than 20 years of risk management and preparedness experience. He’s also the author of Disaster Prep 101.

You may use or reference this story with attribution and a link to

I'm not familiar with Mr. Purcell, but it is great to see this information in a mainstream EM professional journal.  The whole "72 hours is all you need to be prepared for" is so set in people's mind.  I truly believe that "they" promote 72 hours not because that's all that it will take before the FEMA cavalry comes in, but because there was a conscious effort made to promote an idea that is so minor and easy to achieve that anyone can do it and won't "feel bad" for failing.  I agree with Mr. Purcell that 2 weeks is a much more reasonable goal (although for true preppers, that's just a good start.

What do you think?  What do your friends and family use as excuses as to why they won't prepare.


  1. 9. If preparedness were really important it would be taught in school.

    Actually my daughter's school went over preparedness for tornadoes, and about having a prepared bag, and a bicycle helmet at home. Of course we live in tornado alley.

  2. "schools only have so much time and budget to teach the topics they already do"

    Much of what schools teach is desgined to make sure that teachers have jobs. Why do most high schools teach foreign languages? To employ foreign language teachers. 99.9% of people who took a foriegn language in high school cannot speak that language ten years later and if they remember any words at all they are usually swear words. Even English and History is over scheduled and under taught in school. That is they essentially teach the same class each year for four years of high school; same civil war history and little else. Most of what is taught in high school is quickly forgotten and never used again in our lifetimes. I am 69 and have yet to need to conjugate a verb in English or Spanish. I worked in a technical field all my life and rarely used any of the math I took past 1st year algebra. History is my hobby but I learned it after high school and was amazed to discover there were numerous depressions between the civil war and the great depression. What public school has become today is babysitters. Very highly paid and money wasting babysitters.